My Battle with Stage IV Lung Cancer

Letters  Page 4

Darlene wrote...

Dear Bob,
I want to thank you for taking the time and effort to write the chronology of your treatment plan and to be open to answer questions. I happened upon your story and letters when researching Essiac Tea on the internet. And coincidently, a friend of mine had just given me a copy of the part of Dr. Whittaker's book New Cures for Chronic Diseases that dealt with Cancer so I was very interested in reading your story. I have a few questions but let me give you a few details first.

After a sudden onset of illness and jaundice, on January 30, 1999 I was told I had a pancreatic mass that was most likely malignant. After some tests and finding the right surgeon, I underwent a surgical procedure. The cancer had metastized to the liver. I did have some rerouting of major organs, but they left the tumor alone. I am scheduled to start chemo & radiation on April 5th. I am setting up my own treatment plan including prayer, visualization, imagery, Reike, and nutritional supplements as complementary therapy. After reading your story and treatment plan and reading Dr. Whitaker's information (as well as other sources) I have some questions.

Question 1.  Is there a particular reason you did not use Hydrazine Sulfate?

Bob replies...

Hi Darlene, I decided not to try the hydrazine sulfate because it was controversial and I think I read about some deaths due to cross reactions with alcohol. I figured that any one of the five alternatives I did use could possibly effect a cure by itself, so that by trying them all I would have a better chance at a cure. This seems to be the same logic you are using. I think that hydrazine sulfate also requires close monitoring and it didn't seem practical to find a doctor who would administer it while I was already being treated by an oncologist.

Question 2.  Did you make any other major dietary changes when you initiated your treatment plan? What type of dietary regimen did you follow?

I think the steroid treatment before each chemo increased my appetite because I gained 20 pounds. I made no major changes in my diet --I ate whoppers and fries and pizza and an occasional beer or wine, along with Healthy Choice and Lean Cuisine microwave dinners etc., a typical bachelor's diet (but not the recommended diet). I did try juicing, I would juice 1 or 2 pounds of carrots and 4 or 5 apples and drink about 6 ounces a day for several days. Please see the VDB letter below for more on Vitamin A and cancer. I have recently seen articles on possible anti-cancer effects of licorice and feel it is important to mention that during my therapy I probably ate 1 or 2 black licorice vines each weekday, since they were a fringe benefit supplied at my workplace.

Question 3.  Why didn't your plan include shark & bovine cartilage?

I did mention that I tried it briefly (4 or 5 days) but it requires very large doses which gave me lots of gas. Since I have never been fond of taking capsules, and since I read about a study which showed no effect of shark cartilage, I discontinued it. It may still be effective, but there seems to be controversy about differing purity from various manufacturers.

Question 4.  What is the Cat's Claw used for?

Cats Claw Bark (Una De Gato) is from South America. I read stories about people using it to reverse cancer. The National Institute of Health is beginning to investigate various alternative therapies at the University of Texas Center for Alternative Medicine Cancer Research (UTCAM). They have chosen some of the most likely candidates to investigate first, including essiac, cats claw, selenium, and hydrazine sulfate. If you surf around their site you can find more info on these and other agents.


Bev wrote...

My father-in-law was recently diagnosed with asbestosis. We immediately obtained the four herbs and began to give essiac tea to him. He has since had a major operation to relieve the fluid build up in his lungs which would have eventually drowned him. We don't seem to be able to find any information on effectiveness of essiac on asbestosis even though it is a tumor. It is too early to tell if it has been helpful, but we are not going to give up trying. We would appreciate any information relating specifically to asbestosis.

Bob replies...

Bev, I have had one phone call from someone in Long Beach, California who had asbestosis. I gave them some information about alternatives, but I don't know if they decided to try them. I suggest you place a post about asbestosis on the popular Mediconsult Lung Cancer bulletin board, perhaps you get information from readers. If I find anything about asbestosis, I will forward it to you.


VDB wrote:

I emailed you a couple of weeks ago about the oncologist telling my friend not to take supplements containing beta carotene and Vitamin A but to get these only from foods rich in Vitamin A.  On the Mediconsult website, I have found an article concerning that topic called "Effects of a combination of beta carotene and Vitamin A on lung cancer and cardiovascular disease."  Have you read it?

Bob replies...

I looked at the article and I am somewhat confused by some of the contradictions. Maybe the beta carotene and vitamin A do increase risk of getting lung cancer, but may still be helpful in treating it once you have it? Also, some of the chemo agents are most effective on the most rapidly growing cells, so by speeding up their growth rate, they may become more vulnerable to the chemo. Someone should do some more studies to see if this could be true.

In my case the 20,000IU of vitamin A from Whitaker's program plus the extra from juicing the carrots did not seem to have any negative effect. Dr. Lorraine Day at http://www.drday.com is a doctor who recommends and used vast quantities of carrot juice in her own recovery from breast cancer. Again, more studies are needed in this area.


Bonnie wrote...

We have my mother-in-law on the same regimen that you took for your cure. She is a young 68 but doesn't seem to have the fight that we think she should have. Of course her doctors are not encouraging, they are straight forward and it seems to have knocked the wind out of her sails. She did have a bad bout with blood clots which is now under control. She went through radiation with the side affects of no appetite and will start chemo next week.

But we are so concerned, mostly she stares out the window and thinks about death. She used to have a very positive attitude toward life and enjoyed loving her family. We are praying, wanting to see a change in her attitude for her sake. How can we help her?

Bob replies...

I went into a state of shock and denial when my oncologist told me my disease was incurable at the present time. It was scary not knowing how long I had to live and frustrating that the doctor could not tell me anything. He could only tell me that we would have to wait and see how effective the treatment was. I was fortunate to be able to continue working so I didn't have financial worries, but I could not know what the future would bring. Being a fighter, I wasn't about to give up although I certainly realized and accepted the possibility of a limited life span. I was hopeful that I would be in the 40% who get some benefits from the chemo. When my 6 week and 12 week chest x-rays showed no change in my tumor, my oncologist was pleased -- but I wanted more.

Fortunately, during this time my stepson convinced me that he knew of many people who had been cured by various alternative therapies. Initially, I was skeptical but after reading and researching I came to believe that a cure was possible and started the alternatives with a positive attitude.

It helped to talk to a "terminal" patient who was still alive after 4 years on essiac tea. I began my treatment with generally good health which probably helped. Perhaps if your mother-in-law sees some progress in shrinking the tumor she will get back her fighting spirit. I was certainly elated when I got the results of my 7/28/98 CT scan. Hoping the best for her and please stay in touch.


Home   Bob's Story   Letters   Stories
Bob's Updates   Biography   Tribute